|
Chiropractic
Treatment for Migraine
Migraine headaches are
estimated to cost the U.S. over $17 billion each year. While it is clinically
recognized that migraines can be related to cervicogenic conditions, the exact
nature of this relationship is unknown. This study set out to test the effectiveness
of chiropractic treatment for migraines.
123 participants diagnosed
with migraines according to the International Headache Society standard completed
the study. Each participant experienced a minimum of 1 migraine per month,
and had at least 5 of the following indicators: inability to maintain normal
activities/need to seek dark and quiet, pain located around the temples, “throbbing”
pain, symptoms of nausea, vomiting, aura, photophobia or phonophobia, migraine
triggered by weather changes, migraine worsened by head or neck movement,
diagnosis of migraine by a specialist, and a family history of migraine.
The study consisted of
three stages. In the pretreatment stage, researchers collected data on migraine
incidence, intensity, duration, disability and use of medications, this data
was used as a baseline to compare with study results and data collection continued
throughout the trial. For the second stage of research participants were split
into a control group (40) that received a placebo treatment using electrodes
and an experimental group (83) that received a maximum of 16 treatments of
chiropractic spinal manipulative therapy (CSMT). The last 2 months of the
study involved data collection for comparison purposes.
Results showed that those
that received chiropractic treatment had significant improvement in migraine
frequency, duration, disability and lowered medication use in comparison to
the control group. Improvements in migraine frequency and duration for the
chiropractic group are illustrated below. The area of greatest improvement
was medication use, with a significant number of participants reporting that
their medication use was down to zero by the end of the trial. Five participants
reported that migraine symptoms were worse after 2 months of CSMT, but they
did not report intensified symptoms at the post treatment stage.
|
|
|
The authors report that
their study with a 6-month duration is more valid than some previous studies
because studies with shorter durations are too short to allow for the cyclical
nature of migraines. Limited sample size and lack of consideration for what
aspect of CSMT caused the improvements are some limitations of this study.
Researchers also suggest that an improved study method might be to treat the
control group with a sham form of CSMT rather than a treatment that does not
mimic chiropractic. Despite some limitations this research adds to the body
of evidence that suggests chiropractic manipulative therapy can be an effective
treatment for migraine and headaches. The authors conclude:
“A high percentage
(83%) of participants in this study reported stress as a major factor for
their migraines. It appears probable that chiropractic care has an effect
on the physical conditions related to stress and that in these people the
effects of the migraine are reduced. However, further studies are required
to assess how chiropractic SMT may have an effect on migraine morbidity.”
Tuchin PJ, Pollard
H, Bonello R. A randomized controlled trial of chiropractic spinal manipulative
therapy for migraine. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics
2000;23(2):91-95. |